Which Reward Program Should I Start With?
Guides, Banks, Hobby Guidelines

Which Reward Program Should I Start With?

Jason Foley Author Image

Why Order Matters When Getting Started

It’s important to have a strategy when getting started in points and miles. Making the wrong move early can cost you hundreds of thousands of points over time.

Which cards you open first matters just as much as which cards you open. Each bank has its own approval and bonus rules, and some banks become harder to access once you’ve opened several cards. The goal isn't to follow a rigid checklist. It's to understand why the order matters so you can adapt as offers, rules, and loyalty programs change.

Why Flexibility Also Matters

Don't fall in love with one bank. Programs devalue. Rules change. Banks introduce new restrictions. At the same time, limited-time welcome offers create opportunities that can be worth adjusting your plan for. Your strategy should provide direction without locking you into one path.

Our card rankings page is the best place to monitor elevated offers and decide when it's worth adjusting your strategy.

Start With Transferable Points

Co-branded hotel and airline cards lock you into one loyalty program. Transferable points give you flexibility to choose how and when you redeem. For that reason, it makes sense to start with transferable point systems, and Chase is what we recommend starting with.

Why Chase Comes First

Your early card strategy will largely be shaped by two rules, depending on how you apply for business cards.

  • If you apply through a registered business such as an LLC with an EIN, the Chase 5/24 Rule will be the primary rule to follow.
  • If you apply for business cards as a sole proprietor, you'll be more restricted within the Chase ecosystem because of the Chase Business 3/24 Rule.

That creates two different strategies.

If You Apply Through a Registered Business

If you apply through an LLC, S-corp, or other registered business, the traditional 5/24 strategy will be what you follow. For most beginners, that generally means starting with a Sapphire card and adding Chase business cards while you remain under 5/24.

However, with lifetime restrictions on Sapphire cards, no-fee Ink cards, and the Ink Preferred card, when you apply is also important since you can only earn each bonus once.

Here's why Chase remains the best starting point:

  • Start with a Chase card that unlocks airline and hotel transfers. There are four cards that transfer to partners, and that's where Ultimate Rewards become significantly more valuable because of Chase's industry-leading transfer partners.
  • Ultimate Rewards are one of the most flexible transferable currencies. Points can be combined across personal cards, business cards, cash back cards, and spouses.
  • Chase business cards do not add to your 5/24 count. That gives you room to earn additional welcome offers without using up more personal-card slots.

If You Apply as a Sole Proprietor

The strategy is more restrictive if you apply for Chase business cards as a sole proprietor. Under Chase's 3/24 Rule, you should be at 2/24 or lower to give yourself the best chance of approval when applying for any Chase business card.

That makes application order much more important.

If Chase business cards are a priority, think very carefully about which cards you want taking up your first few 5/24 slots. You may want to open one or two Chase personal cards that matter most, then prioritize as many Chase business cards as is feasible while you're still below 3/24.

That does not mean you should automatically open every Chase business card first. Chase now limits welcome offers on many of its best cards to once per lifetime, so elevated offers still matter. The challenge is balancing the value of waiting for a better offer against the risk of reaching 3/24 and loseing access to certain Chase business cards entirely.

Be aware that this rule applies to all Chase business cards, including co-branded ones.

If you're already above 3/24, don't automatically put your entire strategy on hold just to get back to 2/24. Depending on which Chase business cards and welcome offers you're still eligible for, the opportunity cost of passing up personal cards from other banks may not be worth it.

Build Your Chase Foundation, Then Diversify

One thing has changed in recent years: Chase now limits welcome offers on many of its best cards to once per lifetime. Rather than rushing through Chase applications, we recommend being selective and taking advantage of elevated offers whenever possible. This doesn't mean you should never get a Chase card with lifetime restrictions unless the offer is elevated, just that it should be on your radar and you should be selective when it's feasible to do so.

Our card rankings page tracks the best offers available and can help you decide when it's worth applying.

Once you've built the Chase foundation that makes sense for your situation, begin expanding into other transferable points systems instead of continuing to focus exclusively on Ultimate Rewards.

If you're applying through a registered business, staying under 5/24 can still give you flexibility to return to Chase when an elevated offer appears on a card you haven't opened yet.

If you're applying as a sole proprietor, the decision is more complicated. If you're still at 2/24, we advise focusing on business cards from other issuers that don't report to your personal credit so you can continue diversifying without increasing that count. Once you reach 3/24, Chase business cards will become much harder to access.

Don't Wait Too Long on Capital One

After you've handled your highest-priority Chase applications, it often makes sense to add a Capital One card or two.

Capital One approvals become more difficult as you open more cards, so waiting too long can mean missing out entirely. We still generally recommend waiting for an elevated offer, but because Capital One approvals become harder over time, applying at a standard offer is sometimes better than missing the opportunity altogether.

For sole proprietors, this is another reason application order matters. Opening a Capital One personal card while you're at 2/24 would put you at 3/24 and could close the door on Chase business cards. Make sure you've handled your Chase business priorities first, or consider using one of your first two 3/24 slots on Capital One if that card is a higher priority.

Capital One has a smaller lineup, but the Venture Rewards and Venture X are both solid cards with strong signup bonuses and relatively simple reward structures and benefits. Be aware of Capital One's Venture Family Rule and open Venture cards in the correct order so you're eligible for the welcome offers on each.

Expand Into Other Transferable Points Systems

Once you've built your Chase foundation and added one or two Capital One cards, we generally recommend expanding into another transferable points system rather than continuing to concentrate all of your earning in Ultimate Rewards.

Citi ThankYou points are valuable and transferable to a solid set of transfer partners. They are the only issuer that transfers directly to American Airlines, which offers a lot of valuable sweet spots for airline redemptions. Citi doesn’t offer the same quantity of cards for earning points as Chase, but it’s a solid system to diversify with after Chase and Capital One, particularly if you live near an American Airlines hub.

Bilt is a unique points system that allows you to earn points on your mortgage or rent. It can take more planning than other transferable currencies, especially for beginners. But if you can make it work for your situation, it's a powerhouse for earning points, especially with its top card, the Palladium. Plus, it has one of the strongest transfer partner lineups in the hobby, arguably rivaling Chase.

Don't Rush Into Amex

Amex is best used as a supplement to the rest of your points. It is important to be aware of Amex's lifetime restrictions on its cards. In practice, these "lifetime" restrictions are more like 7-10 years, but that's still a long time to wait for another welcome offer. Amex cards are also generally easier to get once you're above 3/24 and 5/24, which is another reason not to rush into them until it makes sense.

Amex has also personalized many welcome offers with "as high as" language. You may see an Amex Business Platinum offer for "as high as 300,000 points," but that does not mean you'll receive 300,000 points. You'll need to fill out the application to see your specific offer, which can vary by person. Fortunately, many Amex applications let you see your offer before accepting the card and triggering a hard pull.

Amex offers great cards and transfer partners, but its lifetime-style restrictions and personalized welcome offers make it harder to plan on earning a specific number of points over the long term.

Your Strategy Will Change

Your first year in the hobby shouldn't look the same as your fourth. Early on, Chase deserves most of your attention because of 5/24, 3/24, and the value of Ultimate Rewards.

If you apply for Chase business cards as a sole proprietor, the first few personal-card slots are especially important because reaching 3/24 can cut off your access to Chase business cards. If you apply through a registered business, you have more flexibility and can continue planning primarily around 5/24.

As your Chase opportunities become more limited, your focus naturally shifts toward other transferable currencies and co-branded cards. That's exactly how a healthy points strategy should evolve.

Putting It All Together

Our recommendation is simple:

  • Start with Chase.
  • Know whether 5/24 or 3/24 will drive your Chase business-card strategy.
  • If you're a sole proprietor, prioritize your most important Chase business card opportunities while you're still at 2/24 or lower.
  • Use our card rankings page before every application to identify elevated offers.
  • Have the flexibility to jump on the right elevated welcome offer rather than following a rigid timeline.
  • Gradually build complementary transferable points systems and eventually co-branded cards instead of relying on a single bank.

That approach gives you the flexibility to adapt as the hobby changes while continuing to maximize the value of every card you apply for.

You Might Also Like

        My Strategy Notes